Sleepy Hollow: The Lost Chapter

by Jeremy Sony
Directed by Jeremy Sony

Oct. 18, 19, 25, 26, Nov. 1, & 2, 2019 at 8:00PM
Oct. 20, 27, & Nov. 3, 2019 at 2:00PM

Nathan Bashaw (Ichabod Crane), Abigail Bauder (Catherine), Randy Benge (Hans van Ripper / Baltus van Tassel), Celia Car (Hanna), Tiarra Dapo (Abigail Seymour), Mia Doron (Samantha), John Grote (Brom Bones), Corbin Kranz (Peter), Adelina Luther (Rose), Rachel Luther (Katrina van Tassel), Chris Metzger (Josephine Koning / Diedre van Hart), Nancy Meyer (Margriet Gelderland / Eleanor van Tassel), JoLayne Morneau (Susanna Koning), Jasmine Rosado (Sarah van Brunt), & Eli Wilson (Nathaniel).

The story picks up in the final pages of Washington Irving's classic, Sleepy Hollow, revealing a previously untold piece of the legend. After Ichabod disappears, his students are determined to find out the truth of what happened. Their new schoolteacher, Abigail Seymour, is more focused on teaching than chasing ghosts - that is until she has her own run in with the Horseman. Now, she and the students must hurry to retrace Ichabod's final night in Sleepy Hollow and find a way to stop the Horseman once and for all. Along the way, we discover new revelations, gain clues on who the Headless Horseman could be and meet all the original Irving characters from The Legend of Sleepy Hollow.

Suitable for audiences of all ages.

Purchase tickets online or call 614.360.1000.

Purchase tickets online for any upcoming show!

Need to exchange your tickets? Click Here! >

See our ticketing policy >

Easily make your Curtain Players donation in The Giving Store!
Visit our page at The Giving Store!


Not only does it feel great to volunteer, house staff see performances for free! Learn more >

Up Next!

In the Spotlight

Casting Announcement for The Mousetrap!

Curtain Players is proud to announce the cast of The Mousetrap by Agatha Christie, following auditions on Sept. 8.  

Congratulations to Diane Hooper (Mrs. Boyle), Rusty Wummel (Mr. Paravacini), Kyle Smith (Sgt. Trotter), Brian Henry (Giles Ralston), Randy Lenhart (Major Metcalf), Greg Kissner (Christopher Wren), Brittany Powers (Miss Casewell) and Rachel Wiltshire (Mollie Ralston).

The Mousetrap runs Dec. 6 – 22, and is directed by Coreen Janetzke.

Everyone's a suspect in Christie's enduring murder-mystery. A group of strangers is stranded in a boarding house during a snowstorm, and one of them is a murderer. A superb evening of intrigue by the foremost mystery writer of her time!

Performances are Fridays and Saturdays, Dec. 6, 7, 13, 14, 20, & 21, 2019 at 8 p.m., and Sundays Dec. 8, 15, & 22 at 2 p.m., with a pay-what-you-can preview on Thursday, Dec. 5 at 8 p.m. Please note the additional matinee on the first Sunday.

Tickets are on sale now at

Recent News

  • Spotlight: Casting Announcement for The Mousetrap!
  • Sep 14: Curtain Players Presents: A Dramatic Reading of Original 'Sleepy Hollow' at Westerville Library, Oct. 4
  • Sep 14: Night of Magic at Wizards & Wands – Oct. 25
  • Aug 25: Curtain Brings History Home at Harlem Township Days
  • Aug 01: Casting Announcement! 'Sleepy Hollow: The Lost Chapter'
  • Jul 30: August Civic Event Volunteers Needed – Bringing Community Theatre to Our Community!
  • Jul 30: Leading Ladies Set Build, Part Two – Aug. 3
  • Jul 28: Set Build Party A Success — Thank You, Volunteers!
  • Jul 17: Cast Announced for "16-3-3, Home"
  • Jul 14: This Amazon Prime Day, Set Your Smile Donations to CP
  • See all Curtain Players news. >
Thanks to Our Supporting Organizations:
Logo for Delaware County Foundation
Program and Capital Improvement Support
Curtain Players is an award-winning theater serving the central-Ohio area. We have been routinely recognized by AACT, OCTA, and Theatre Roundtable for our tradition of excellence. Learn more about who we are!